What happened with KMX today?
No read yet
Uses news and trading volume to explain the day’s move and how it relates to the market.
Stop guessing. Get the call, a three-month target price, the best and worst cases, and a source for every claim.
CarMax’s main business is selling used vehicles to U.S. retail buyers at no-haggle prices, online, in stores or through both. It sources a substantial share of its inventory directly from consumers. Vehicles that meet its retail standards go to retail buyers; those that do not are sold to licensed dealers through its own wholesale auctions. Retail vehicle sales account for most revenue, with wholesale sales a smaller part.
Most retail buyers finance their purchases. CarMax Auto Finance (CAF) lends only to customers buying CarMax retail vehicles and earns interest and fees, with funding costs and unpaid loans reducing what it keeps. CarMax also arranges financing through outside lenders, so sales partly depend on those lenders continuing to offer credit. CAF funds most of its loans by packaging auto loans into securities sold to investors.
The vehicle business depends on buying enough suitable cars and selling them before falling used-car prices erode margins; the lending business depends on borrowers repaying and continued access to funding. CarMax lacks manufacturer authorization to perform recall repairs, so some vehicles it sells may have unrepaired safety recalls.
The risk section is the longest, dullest part of the filing. This keeps only what can really hurt you: where it hits, how hard, when it plays out.
Every company claims an edge. Each one is checked against hard numbers like margins and returns: which hold, and which line gives way first.
Carvana competes directly with CarMax nationwide for used-car purchases and buyers, on price, selection, convenience and financing. Watch its online retail vehicle sales: each sale also opens opportunities to earn revenue from financing, add-on products and trade-ins.
Lithia Motors, Inc.'s dealerships and Driveway platform compete with CarMax for used-car buyers and the financing and protection products sold alongside their cars. Its used-vehicle business is the relevant comparison, rather than its broader sales of new cars and repair services.
AutoNation, Inc. competes with CarMax for U.S. used-car buyers and their financing and insurance business. Both lend to their own vehicle customers and offer third-party products; AutoNation also earns commissions for arranging outside financing, making its used-car and finance results the closer comparison.
Sonic Automotive competes with CarMax for U.S. used-car shoppers through its EchoPark used-car stores and franchised dealerships.
Asbury Automotive Group, Inc. competes with CarMax for dealership used-car sales and the financing and protection products buyers purchase with them. Asbury arranges loans through third parties and sells finance and insurance products through Total Care Auto, so the overlap extends beyond the vehicle sale.
Group 1 Automotive, Inc.'s U.S. dealerships and digital platform compete with CarMax for used-car buyers, financing and vehicle service-contract sales. Watch its U.S. used-car business and fees from arranging loans and selling third-party service and insurance contracts, rather than treating its U.K. operations as the same overlap.
Penske Automotive's U.S. dealerships compete with CarMax to sell used cars to retail buyers, but its international and commercial-truck businesses make its overall results a less direct comparison.
ACV Auctions Inc. competes with CarMax's wholesale auctions to sell used vehicles to licensed dealers, connecting sellers and buyers through online auctions and remarketing centers. For CarMax, this competition concerns vehicles that fail its retail standards, not cars sold to consumers.
OPENLANE, Inc competes with CarMax's wholesale auctions for dealer buyers and used vehicles to sell. OPENLANE charges buyers and sellers transaction fees, so its marketplace business is the relevant comparison for CarMax's sales of vehicles that do not meet retail standards.
Ally Financial both competes with CarMax's own lending arm, CAF, for auto loans and provides financing to CarMax vehicle buyers. Its auto-lending business therefore matters in two ways: as a rival to CAF and as an outside source of loans for CarMax customers.
America's Car Mart Inc competes with CarMax in selling and financing used cars, but focuses on older vehicles and buyers with limited resources or credit problems. It finances nearly all its buyers itself, making sales to customers who cannot qualify for conventional loans the more relevant comparison as CAF expands across credit tiers.
Credit Acceptance Corp and CarMax's CAF both face used-car loan demand and borrower defaults, but this does not establish a financing-provider relationship between them. Credit Acceptance takes over loans originated by dealers and collects borrowers' payments, while CAF lends only to CarMax buyers; repayment performance is the useful comparison.
Ally Financial Inc. earningsALLY
Ally Financial's report will show how auto lending and borrower repayment affect financing for CarMax customers, while revealing how Ally competes with CarMax's own lending arm.
Read Ally's auto-loan originations alongside credit losses. Steady lending with contained losses would show that outside financing can still serve CarMax buyers, while Ally remains a rival for their loans. Falling originations or rising losses would point to harder-to-get financing for customers and more pressure on CarMax to serve them through CAF.
Initial Jobless Claims (Oct/17)
For CarMax, weekly claims count new applications for unemployment benefits, a signal of job security that can affect customers’ ability to buy its used cars and repay CAF auto loans.
Expected200.0KLast release199.0K
If it comes in above expectations
If the reading is above the 200.0K estimate, it is above the previous 199.0K. More claims suggest a weakening job market; customers may delay used-car purchases, while more CAF borrowers could struggle to repay, raising loan losses.
If it comes in below expectations
Fewer claims suggest a steadier job market; customers may be more willing to buy used cars and CAF borrowers better able to repay, easing pressure on loan losses.
Carvana Co. earningsCVNA
Carvana's report will show whether it can sell more used cars while protecting profit per car, a key measure of its competition with CarMax for buyers.
Compare Carvana's retail unit sales with gross profit per unit. More sales with per-car profit holding up would show it attracting buyers without clearly sacrificing the economics of each sale, making it harder for CarMax to win shoppers. Weaker sales or thinner per-car profit would offer less evidence that Carvana is taking customers profitably, and could ease that competitive pressure.
Fed Interest Rate Decision
For CarMax, Fed rate decisions shape what customers pay to borrow for used cars and what CAF earns after its own loan-funding costs.
Expected4.0%Last release4.0%
If it comes in above expectations
If rates rise, higher borrowing costs may make customers less able to afford CarMax vehicles and weaken sales; CAF may also pay more to fund loans, though it could earn more interest on new loans.
If it comes in below expectations
If rates fall, lower borrowing costs may make CarMax vehicles more affordable and support sales; CAF may also pay less to fund loans, though interest earned on new loans could decline.
ACV Auctions Inc. earningsACVA
ACV Auctions' report will show how much dealers and sellers use its online wholesale marketplace, a competing channel for CarMax's vehicles sold to dealers rather than retail buyers.
Read activity on ACV's marketplace alongside revenue per transaction. Active trading with revenue per transaction holding up would show sellers and dealers continuing to use an alternative channel, giving CarMax more competition when it sells non-retail vehicles to dealers. Weaker activity or lower revenue per transaction would suggest that channel may be losing some pull.
Non Farm Payrolls (Oct)
The monthly jobs report counts jobs added or lost, a signal of employment and income that can affect demand for CarMax’s used cars and CAF borrowers’ ability to repay.
For CarMax, stronger job growth would point to better support for used-car purchases and CAF repayments; weaker growth would point to more pressure on both, although the report does not show how much customers spend or whether specific borrowers repay.
Retail Sales MoM (Oct)
Retail sales track consumer spending at retailers, a signal that can affect demand and margins for CarMax’s used-vehicle sales, its largest revenue source.
For CarMax, stronger retail spending would point to more support for used-car demand and sales margins; weaker spending would suggest customers may pull back, putting those outcomes under pressure.
America's Car Mart Inc earningsCRMT
America's Car Mart's report will show whether buyers with weaker credit are still buying used cars and repaying loans, a reference point as CarMax expands CAF across credit tiers.
Read America's Car Mart's vehicle sales alongside loan losses. Steady sales with contained losses would suggest buyers with weaker credit still want cars and lending can remain workable, a useful reference as CarMax broadens CAF across credit tiers. Falling sales or rising losses would point to pressure on demand or lending returns in that market. America's Car Mart sells older vehicles to a different customer base, so its results are not a direct read-through to CarMax.
CarMax Inc. earningsThis company
CarMax's report will show whether it can protect profit on each retail used car while its own auto-lending business adds earnings without higher credit costs.
Read retail used-vehicle gross profit per unit alongside unit sales, then compare CarMax Auto Finance (CAF) income with its provision for loan losses. Stable per-car profit and sales, with CAF income not eroded by rising loss provisions, would show that CarMax's buying, pricing and lending are supporting both earnings streams. Lower per-car profit or sales, or weaker CAF income with higher provisions, would point to mounting pressure in its retail or lending business.
